Is organic food really worth it?

organic1There are any number of claims made in relation to organic food. It is often claimed that organically produced food is intrinsically healthier and more nutritious than its conventionally produced, ‘non-organic’ counterpart. Supermarkets and grocers tend to charge a premium price for organically produced foodstuffs, but is there any real difference between organic foods and the rest of the produce on supermarket shelves? Are organic foods really worth the extra costs involved?

Organic Food: The Facts

First of all, the term ‘organic food’ is somewhat of a misnomer, as almost all foodstuffs are technically ‘organic’. Organic food refers to food that is produced without the use of synthetic fertilisers and pesticides. This definition is problematic, however; various producers of organic food apply differing standards as to what food production methods can be classified as ‘organic’. For example, artificial pesticides are used by some producers of certified organic foods, but only as a last resort. So consumers could be paying more for food labelled as ‘organic’ when in fact it may not fit in with their notion of the term.

As to organic food’s supposed health and nutritional properties, there has never been any evidence to suggest that organically produced food is in any way superior to its conventionally produced rivals. Two studies commissioned by the United Kingdom’s Food Safety Authority in 2009 found that there were “no important differences in the nutrition content, or any additional health benefits, of organic food when compared with conventionally produced food.” So if you’re shelling out the extra money for organic tomatoes on the basis that they’re better for you, think again.

In support of organic foods

There are arguments to be made in support of organic foods. Overuse of pesticides and fertilisers in food produced under standard methods can contaminate groundwater; organic foods reduce the use of these chemicals. And organically produced fruit and vegetables don’t undergo the irradiation that conventionally produced fruits and vegetables go through in order to ensure their shelf life. What this means is that the organic strawberries that you’re buying were probably grown Ireland, rather than flown here from South Africa. This benefits the local economy by supporting Irish agricultural jobs, while also benefitting the environment by reducing the ‘food miles’ of your shopping basket.

Rather than paying the price for organic foods, why not make an effort to buy locally grown, in-season fresh produce instead? Buying local lets you feel good about what you buy through supporting local jobs and saving the environment - without organic foods’ hefty price tag.

Tags: ,

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (6 votes, average: 3.33 out of 5)

Loading ... Loading ...

3 Responses to “Is organic food really worth it?”

  1. JAMES says:

    Very well written and well BALANCED article. Interesting and food for thought…
    James Nolan

  2. Claire says:

    Interesting article. I live in East Cork and is it the same all over the country but the incidence of cancer here is scary. Is anyone doing a survey of where pockets are happening and why? I believe organic has to be better than conventionally grown food. Because of friends and close family members dying of cancer we opt to source organic where we can. I treat it with more respect, I use every little bit of it. Flavour is better. We go regularly to our brill Farmers Market and this year after losing my parents in last two years and caring for them we now have time again (sadly) to get back to our veg patch. This recession is good…..people are using old skills again before they are lost forever with the death of parents, grandparents…we need to pass skills on and show our kids how to grow their own organic foods. We live in fishing area and to see the sensible immigrants Polish, Lithuanian, Malaysian fishing off the local harbour….they are right …..I do often wonder though is fish safe now or not? All the questions. You are right if you cannot buy organic or afford it buy local and you get the trace elements of your local soil plus support local suppliers/business and get to know your neighbours. Life can be tough but its good to get back to basics back to nature/soil.

    Claire

  3. admin says:

    Hi Claire,

    First of all, I am very sorry to hear that you lost you your parents recently; as one who has lost a parent to cancer themselves, I can emphathise. As per your cancer concerns: please refer to the link to the Food Safety Authority’s article on organic foods - “there are NO important differences in the nutrition content, or any additional health benefits, of organic food when compared with conventionally produced food.” - (I added the bold capitals)

    Eating organic foods makes you no more or less likely to contract cancer. I am not a doctor, however, so if you have concerns in this regard, please consult a medical practitioner.

    As to concern to the safety of foodstuffs generally, we have a very stringent system of food safety checks and balances in this country. Please see the Food Safety Authority website FAQ for details.

    All the best,

    Cathal, SaveAFewBob Team

Have Your Say